This time of year, high school baseball teams throughout New Jersey are figuring out who will replace their graduated seniors for the upcoming season. Maybe a pitcher or two here, or a hitter or two there.
South Plainfield will have to face more than most.
Getting some measure of redemption after a tough, late-inning loss to Ramapo in the North 2, Group 3 finals in 2024, the Tigers took the title last season, beating Colonia in the final, with a veteran group.
Now, much of that core is gone.
Of their top four pitchers by innings thrown, three are gone – Kevin Penny, Mike Castagna, and Ryan Balent – while Aiden McCarthy (1.34 ERA in 52 1/2 innings pitched) and Jayden Jiminez (2.29 ERA, 18 1/3 IP) are back.
On defensive alignment, head coach Scott Gleichenhaus will have to replace catcher Steve Studlack, as well as his middle infield combo of shortstop Dan Kapsch (.323, 24 RBI) and second baseman Nick Irizzary (.3878. 17 RBI). His corner infielders, David Butrico in left, Balent in right) are also gone.
Then again, with a real blue collar group, some is bound to step up. McCarthy will be in the lineup everyday at first base if he’s not on the mount, and he hit .297 last year with 25 RBIs to led the team.
And the Tigers also will look to senior Dom Massaro for major contributions and leadership. Massaro, CJSR’s Special Teams Returner of the Year in football, hit .394 last year – best among the regulars – knocked in 20 runs and stole 38 bases, good for No. 2 on the team last season.
Click below to hear South Plainfield head coach Scott Gleichenhaus talk about the Tigers’ upcoming 2026 season with Central Jersey Sports Radio’s Mike Pavlichko:













