Even as the second seed in the Central Jersey Group 1 section, Piscataway Magnet’s season has been somewhat of a Cinderella run.
But the clock struck midnight for the Raiders (25-4) in the sectional semifinals, falling to third-seeded Point Pleasant Beach 14-2 in five innings.
The battle-tested Garnet Gulls (17-6) piled on runs early and often, including an eight-run third inning, to send them to their sixth consecutive sectional final appearance.
Point Pleasant Beach opened up the game with two runs and plenty of pressure on the basepaths, as the first two pitches of the game were swung on and resulted with a batter on base.
Centerfielder Brody Powers brought both of them home with a rare two-RBI sacrifice fly, after the ball was slow to come back into the infield. Raiders starter Jack Garrison got out of any further trouble with a groundout to end the inning.
Piscataway Magnet threatened in its half of the first, as shortstop Trey Lyerly made it to second base on an error in the outfield. But Garnet Gulls starter Tommy Conroy worked a groundout of his own to keep the Raiders off the board.
Conroy helped his own case with an RBI single in the top half of the second, after right fielder Davin Marquez got plunked with two outs. He once again worked around some trouble on the basepaths in the second, with a hit-by-pitch and a fielder’s choice, before striking out designated hitter Tristen Miller to end the second.
Then the floodgates opened in the top of the third.
Point Pleasant Beach broke the game open with eight runs, turning a three-run lead into an 11-0 ballgame. Catcher Danny Lubach – who recorded his 150th career hit in the game – reached on an error to lead it off. Powers then put runners on second and third with a double, prompting a Piscataway Magnet pitching change. Brody Guthrie replaced Garrison, but the change didn’t faze the Garnet Gulls.
Third baseman Carson Pfeifer brought home Lubach’s courtesy runner, Jalen Kreiger, on a sacrifice fly, recorded after a diving catch by centerfielder Vincent Canavan. It appeared the third-base umpire called Kreiger out for leaving early, but the call was reversed, and Kreiger was safe at home.
After another hit-by-pitch, designated hitter Thomas Slobiski brought in two runs with a single. Those two plays cycled once again, with another hit-by-pitch and then an RBI single from Marquez to make it four runs in the inning and seven on the game.
But Point Pleasant Beach still wasn’t done.
The Raiders made another pitching change after just one out was recorded. Third baseman Colton Lyerly made the move to the mound to face the top of the order for Point Pleasant Beach’s third time through. Conroy walked on five pitches, then second baseman Mason Sesny flew out to right field to record the second out.
But Lubach came back up to bat for the second time in the inning, and took full advantage of the opportunity. He crushed a fastball, sending it over the fence to make it 11-0.
Powers struck out to end the inning, but not before the Garnet Gulls put up eight runs with ten batters, on four hits, two walks, and an error.
With the big lead, Point Pleasant Beach opted to make a pitching change of its own, relieving Conroy after two shutout innings on 38 pitches, saving his potential pitch count for Friday’s sectional final.
Slobiski came in to relieve Conroy, and continued the strong pitching. He threw two shutout innings, allowing just one two baserunners on a single and error.
In the top half of the fourth, the Garnet Gulls added three more runs for good measure. First baseman Dylan Ryan singled to bring home shortstop Antonio Acevedo, Marquez walked, and with the lineup card flipped over and two outs, Conroy added his second and third RBIs of the game with a double into the outfield to make it 14-0.
After two shutout halves in the bottom of the fourth and top of the fifth, Piscataway Magnet had one final shot.
Senior Michael Schimpf – the lone senior on the entire Raiders’ roster – worked a full-count walk in his final game. The next two batters were retired, and with two outs, Piscatway Magnet got on the board with the top of the lineup. Canavan lined a triple into right field to score the first run, and Lyerly brought him in with a flared single to left field.
The Raiders’ magical season comes to a close, with a 25-4 record and sparkling 12-0 mark in the GMC Gold division. They won their first two playoff games in (what we think is) program history, both in walk-off fashion.
And with a young team after a playoff run, the future is bright for Piscatway Magnet.
Point Pleasant Beach will move on to the Central Jersey Group 1 final for the sixth straight year, and the Garnet Gulls will host fifth-seeded Shore, who knocked off top-seeded Middlesex 2-0 in the opposite semifinal. This marks the first year Point Pleasant Beach will not face the Blue Jays in the sectional tournament since 2016.
Click below to hear Central Jersey Sports Radio’s Alec Crouthamel talk with Piscataway Magnet head coach Greg Sampson about the Raiders’ season and loss to Point Pleasant Beach in the Central Jersey Group 1 semifinals, presented by the Sportsplex at Metuchen:





