The Jim Muldowney GMC Championship Tournament semifinals are set for Saturday after a wild quarterfinal round on Wednesday.
The biggest story line of the night was top-seed Edison getting eliminated by nine-seed Monroe, which now appears to be the tournament’s Cinderella, having beaten two higher-seeded teams to make it to Saturday’s semis at East Brunswick Magnet School.
Scroll through for full recaps of all games, including links to separate game stories on Edison-Monroe and Middlesex-St. Thomas Aquinas, including postgame interviews and a look ahead to Saturday’s matchups, which can be heard live on Central Jersey Sports Radio, with Mike Pavlichko and Justin Sontupe on the call:
(9) Monroe 9, (1) Edison 0: Coming into the season, the Eagles had three starting pitchers headed to Division 1 schools, a nice luxury to have. And while Mounmouth-bound Connor Murphy has been outstanding, Robert Roma and Dom Innocenti – both of whom will play at Wagner – have been beset by injuries of late. Innocenti hasn’t taken the mound since a 14-0 loss to Woodbridge on April 23, and Roma – though his team won all four games – had only thrown five times for the Eagles, never going more than three innings in each of his last four appearances.
But he had trouble early on Wednesday, facing just four batters and giving up a single, two doubles and a walk, and two runs before being pulled by head coach Vinnie Abene. And Monroe did more damage with three int he second, one in the fourth, and three in the third.
The Falcons pounded out eleven hits, with Alex Marcus picking up four RBIs, while Justin Mangano went 3-for-4 with two runs scored and one RBI.
(5) South Plainfield 7, (4) Metuchen 6: The Tigers (13-10) saw a 3-0 lead slip away early, and nearly saw a 7-3 lead go by the boards, but hung on in the end to pull off the upset at Metuchen (16-6).
Dom Massaro went 3-for-5, scoring twice, as did Aiden McCarthy and Andrew Bena, and South Plainfield also capitalized on five Bulldog errors. Bena went 5 2/3 innings and got the win, allowing six runs on eight hits, striking out five, while Jayden Jiminez closed it out.
Massaro led off the game with a double, and after a walk to McCarthy, Bena drove in a run with a double. A sac bunt and a strikeout followed, but a single by Anthony Cicenia to center drove in two to make it 3-0.
But Metuchen clawed right back. James Fenton hit a one-out two-run homer in the bottom of the inning to cut it to 3-2, and Matt Jelleme had an RBI single in the second to even things up.
The two played the next three innings scoreless before South Plainfield burst out with four runs in the top of the sixth. Alex Pigna reached on an error, and Dom Massaro replaced him, reaching on a fielder’s choice to second. McCarthy then followed with a single to right to give the Tigers a 4-3 lead.
But South Plainfield wanted more, and they got it. Bena hit a ball to second and reached on an error, bringing in McCarthy to make it 5-3. Chris Loniewski reached on an error by the shortstop. After Ed Budzinski struck out, Cicenia hit a ball to third, and yet another error allowed him to reach, scored Bena, and gave the Tigers a 6-3 lead. The seventh run came in on a line drive single to left by Gabriel Garcia.
Now, it was Metuchen’s turn to keep things interesting. After a fly ball out, Sean Dereka walked, Ryan Alessi singled, and Mason Messina was plunked by Bena. Joseph Tamburello popped out to short center, leaving the bases loaded with two outs. Jelleme got hit to cut it to 7-4, then James Fenton drove in two with a single to left to make it 7-6, before Cooper Crawford grounded into a fielder’s choice, with Cicenia tossing to second for the force.
South Plainfield had two on with two out in the top of the seventh, but failed to get an insurance run. Then, Metuchen got back to business. After a ground out, Lucas Malamug and Sean Dereka hit back-to-back singles. A line out to right by Alessi made the second out.
Then, with an 0-2 count on the next hitter, Jiminez – who came on in relief with two out in the sixth – stepped off the rubber. Dereka on first took off, and Jiminez threw to the shortstop covering. Now in a rundown, the Tigers saw Malamug off third base, and they threw to the third-baseman Pigna, who tagged Malamug for the final out.
(2) Middlesex 3, (7) St. Thomas Aquinas 0: The Blue Jays are back in the semifinals for a second straight year, thanks in large part to yet another outstanding performance from Chris Kozak, who scattered three hits in a complete-game shutout, taking only 89 pitches to do it.
Scoreless through three, Middlesex broke through in the third with Sean Hughes scoring on a wild pitch, and pinch-hitter extraordinaire Dalton Michael driving in two with a single to left field; all three runs came with two outs, and it was all Middlesex needed.
(3) Old Bridge 1, (6) Woodbridge 0: For the second straight game, the Knights (16-8) won a 1-0 game, but this time it was in extra innings, on a walkoff single by Erich Schickschneit. Hits were at a premium, as Old Bridge outhit the Barrons 6-3. And they almost broke the game open in the bottom of the first.
After a one, two, three top of the inning, Chris Crosta led off the home half getting hit by a pitch. Matt Chin struck out, Jared Volpe singled, Rocco Pluchino struck out, and Schickschneit was intentionally walked to load the bases. But Michael Chiarella struck out to end the inning.
All the while, the starting pitchers were dealing. Woodbridge’s Michael Gurovich pitched into the eighth, allowing just three more hits the rest of the game, striking out ten. Blake Dunleavy allowed just three hits and struck out four.
Tied at the end of seven, the game went to extras. Dunleavey threw a solid eighth, getting three groundouts. In the bottom of the inning for Old Bridge, Jared Volpe singled to center with one out. Diego Colon struck out, and Schnickschneit came up. Jared Volpe stole second – his second steal of the game – and on a 1-1 pitch, Schickschneit got the game-winning hit.
It’ll be a second trip to the GMC Tournament semifinals in three years for Old Bridge, which won it all back in 2024.
UPCOMING SCHEDULE:
Jim Muldowney GMC Championship Tournament Semifinals
Saturday, May 16, at East Brunswick Magnet School
- 12 pm: (5) South Plainfield (13-10) vs. (9) Monroe (10-12)
- 2:30 pm: (3) Old Bridge (16-8) vs. (2) Middlesex (20-2)
You can hear both games live on Central Jersey Sports Radio with Mike Pavlichko and Justin Sontupe on the call by clicking here.
Jim Muldowney GMC Championship Tournament Final
Saturday, May 23, at East Brunswick Magnet School (2 pm – LIVE on CJSR)






