South Plainfield seeks back-to-back titles when Tigers visit Cranford in North 2, Group 3 title game

When the South Plainfield Tigers take the field in Cranford today for the North Jersey, Section 2, Group 3 sectional final, they’ll try and become the first GMC school to win back to back titles since Middlesex (four straight from 2017-2019, and 2021), and the first ever from the CJSR-area to successfully defend a Group 3 sectional title.

But if you asked head coach Scott Gleichenhaus before the season whether this team would be back playing for a title, considering all his team lost, he might not have been so sure.

Hopeful, yes? But in the state tournament – or anywhere else for that matter – there’s no guarantee. There are so many examples this year alone – Edison, Immaculata, Middlesex – of some really good teams whose seasons are done right now, while the Tigers are still playing.

Despite losing players like Nick Irizarry, Dan Kapsch, and Steve Studlack, and pitchers like Mike Castagna and Kevin Penny – who got the win in last year’s sectional final at Colonia – South Plainfield (17-11) has persevered.

This afternoon at 3 pm, the fourth-seeded Tigers play third-seed Cranford (20-9) in the North 2, Group 3 final. And like South Plainfield – which got here with a late rally in a 4-2 win at top-seed Chatham in Wednesday’s semifinals – the Cougars also got here via an upset, a 9-3 win at second-seed North Hunterdon.

Cranford is in its second season under Ryan Matlosz, after the departure of veteran mentor Dennis McCaffery, who later resurfaced at St. Joseph-Metuchen, and brought the Falcons to a GMC Tournament championship last season in his inaugural campaign there.

They were knocked out of the Union County Tournament in the quarterfinals by eventual champion A.L. Johnson, but have outscored their opponents 40-12 in three state tournament games so far.

Offensively, they are led by junior shortstop Brayden Fry, hitting .439 on the season with a team-best 21 RBI, but otherwise are hitting .266 as a team. The Cougars likely will go with either one of two juniors: Tyler Muccigrosso (5.76 ERA) or Christian Pereira (3.28 ERA), or some combination of the two.

Basketball big man Andrew Bena is expected to get the nod for the Tigers. He’s 4-2 with a 3.84 ERA, and he’s been a bright spot for both teams this year, a nice starter on the mount to complement Aiden “The Bull” McCarthy, who got the win in the semifinals.

Offensively, speedy centerfielder Dom Massaro is one of the top hitters in the state, at .525 with 26 runs batted in, while Aiden McCarthy (.349) has knocked in 27 to lead the team. Bena is hitting .301 and has driven in 26 for a team that is as aggressive on the base paths as anyone.

South Plainfield is seeking its fourth title overall. In addition to last year’s championship, the Tigers won Central Jersey Group 3 in 1975, and North 2, Group 3 in 2015 under Anthony Guida, finishing 24-8 and winning the state Group 3 title. That year, they beat Cranford in the sectional final, 4-2, then beat North 1 champ Mount Olive in the state semis, 3-1, before taking down Northern Burlington, 8-4, to win the Group 3 championship at Toms River North HS.

Click here to listen to Scott Gleichenhaus’ postgame interview from Wednesday’s semifinal win at Chatham with Central Jersey Sports Radio’s Mike Pavlichko: