Have you ever seen a high school football game with four kickoff returns for touchdowns?
Neither did we until this year.
But that’s what happened on September 6 at Kenny Armwood Stadium, where Jahai Johnson of Piscataway had three of them in a game the Chiefs would lose 52-48, one of those “whoever scores last wins” type of contests.
It was back-and-forth all night, with Johnson trying to will his team to victory.
He started with an 80-yard kick return for a score in the second quarter. When Bridgewater-Raritan’s Nick DiEsso took the opening kick of the second half to the house, Johnson answered with one from 69 yards away. Then, he added one more for 89 yards, and that was the one that impressed everyone the most.
That’s because he broke more than a half-dozen tackles on his way to the end zone. And as the fans decided the Highlight Reel Play of the Year for 2024, it appears the voters were impressed as well.
Johnson got 711 votes, 49 percent of all the votes cast last week, beating out three other contenders.
Click below to see Johnson’s winning Highlight Reel play, then scroll further down to hear him talk with Central Jersey Sports Radio’s Alec Crouthamel:
Click below to hear Central Jersey Sport Radio’s Alec Crouthamel talk with Piscataway senior Jahai Johnson:
Honorable Mentions:
- Fourth Place: Laivon Balthazar and Brandon Bradsher, Perth Amboy: The pair hook up on a long pass play for a touchdown early against JFK in Week Zero, helping the Panthers to their only win of the season.
- Third Place: Kamr McLean, Governor Livingston: His long kickoff return gave the Highlanders the lead, and they hung on for a big road win over Voorhees.
- Second Place: Max Austin, Bernards: His pick-six at the 19-yard line helped the Mountaineers take a big lead and put away Hillside early in a big rivalry game.
Click here to watch all four clips in our original fan vote video!










