Less than 24 hours after the Spotswood football team finished off an 8-2 season – snubbed by the NJSIAA’s UPR playoff formula in favor of 3-5 Camden Eastside on a strength of schedule tiebreaker – head coach Chris Meagher has stepped down.
Meagher coached the Chargers for four seasons, and after a 1-8 campaign in his first, a rebuilding year, Spotswood never won fewer than seven games his next four seasons, going 7-3 in 2022, then 8-2 in 2023, last season, and this year.
And the 2025 team was something special. They started the year 6-0 and never allowed more than eight points in a game until a 20-19 loss to Dayton, where they scored a late touchdown, decided to go for two after a penalty on the PAT try, but got stopped just short of the goal line.
They rebounded with a 41-8 win at South Hunterdon, and a 26-16 win over Roselle Park. While the finished the regular season with three victories over five-win clubs, it was no match for the state’s playoff formula.
While Spotswood will lose talented seniors like QB/DE Se’mir Tolbert-Brimage, RB/LB Sebby Saracino, and excellent kicker Gavin Pereira, they’ll return sophomore wideout and defensive back Ryan Foster, as well as backup QB Jon Regan and sophomore defensive lineman Tyrus Lazar in 2026.
As far the the head coaching job, one potential candidate – if he wants it – could be Andy Steinfeld, the former East Brunswick coach who joined his son, Matt, on Meagher’s staff this season. Meagher called the hire “a home run” back in the preseason.

Steinfeld spent five years coaching at East Brunswick, going 18-28, but going 4-4 during the COVID year.
Meagher – a health and physical education teacher – had been coaching at North Brunswick under Mike Cipot prior to Spotswood, leaving a teaching job there to lead the Chargers. But in the time since, he was unable to get a job in the high school, instead working at Schoenly, an elementary school in the district.
The small high school has only five phys ed/health teachers, and it’s a district that typically has very little turnover. But coaches often prefer to work in the same building where they coach, otherwise it leads to them getting to practice on a daily basis later than the rest of the staff.

Meagher is leaving to take a teaching job at Edison High School, his alma mater, where he graduated in 2007. And he says he wanted to let Spotswood know as soon as possible so the administration could get a head start on the hiring process.
Click below to hear Chris Meagher talk about stepping down as Spotswood head coach with Central Jersey Sports Radio’s Mike Pavlichko:












