It was the beginning of a new month and a perfect day for baseball, but the ending was anything but.
Top-seeded Immaculata saw its season come to a close with Tuesday afternoon out at Diamond Nation in Flemington, with a 1-0 loss to fifth-seed Christian Brothers Academy, the Shore Conference Tournament champions.
Locked in a scoreless tie heading into extra innings, the deciding blow was junior outfielder Alex Fiore’s lead-off solo home run for CBA in the top of the eighth.
It was the first between the two schools since 2015, when the Colts took a 14-4 win in the semifinals of the section.
With the expectation to start senior pitcher Ryan Auten in a potential title appearance on Thursday, Immaculata head coach Kevin Cust opted to start senior pitcher Cole Raymond on the mound, who delivered in the highest way, pitching 6 2/3 innings, allowing no runs, two hits, five walks and collecting four strikeouts.
Both teams struggled to find any hitting in the game, which saw the two combine for nine hits over the course of eight innings. While Raymond arguably performed the best on the mound, the combination of senior pitcher Dan Pardini and junior Declan Doogan was enough to advance the Colts.
Immaculata left three runners stranded on base in the bottom of the first, coming from an error, a walk, and a hit by pitch, but sophomore first baseman Andrew Wheeler grounded to third, ending the inning.
Raymond quickly rolled momentum into the second inning, earning his third punchout and retiring the side. But once again with runners on second and third, senior pitcher Dan Pardini delivered a strikeout to end the inning and survive the scoreless game through two.
Raymond’s greatest challenge came in the top of the third inning, when CBA found themselves with runners on second and third, a full count, and two outs. Down to the last strike, Raymond saw a pitch get away from him and load the bases. Junior Ryan Wetmore stepped up to the plate with the chance to flip the game with one swing of the bat, and it looked that way, but a high fly ball into right field fell short and kept the game scoreless.
The bottom of the third is where the pitching duel emerged, as Pardini rolled through three batters, securing three outs — two groundouts and a strikeout. Though Raymond responded, as the top of the fourth was complete in less than ten pitches from Raymond, who had still not allowed his first hit.
In the top of the fifth, senior third baseman Parker Hughes recorded the first hit of the game for CBA as he placed a ground ball into left field that split the third baseman and shortstop, eventually winning the race to first base. Hughes would advance to second after a groundout by Alex Fiore, but just like the trend of the game, CBA would groundout and flyout, ending the side.
Sophomore Luca Catanzarite, the team’s leading batter, picked up his second hit when he punched a single into left field, who would then advance to second after an error from Pardini, who attempted a pickoff. Catanzarite would advance to third after a wild pitch went past the glove of Colts’ catcher Griffin Kilcullen. The pitch marked the end of Dardini’s day as Doogan emerged on the mound with two outs left in the bottom of the fifth.
Despite a pitching change from CBA, Immaculata decided to stick with Raymond in the sixth inning, where he efficiently got through the inning in less than 10 pitches.
Junior centerfielder Nehemiah Diaz was hit by a pitch to open the bottom of the inning, who would see himself advanced to second base after a bunt attempt from Wheeler. As the inning went on Doogan began to gain confidence and control of the game, fending off a couple of dangerous contact swings from the Spartans. Doogan would punch out freshman Bryson Auten, the eighth batter in the order, retiring the side in a game that remained scoreless.
Bryson Auten replaced Raymond in the seventh with one out, and in his first batter faced, Hughes would hit into a double play that would once again leave the Colts wishing for more and failing to execute.
The bottom of the seventh – and a chance to end the game on a walkoff – came up short for Immaculata, who got a two-out double from Justin Labrador, but a pop out to short ended that threat.
As the game entered crunch time and nervous fans, family, and players surfaced, Fiore broke the seal, crushing a high-flying ball into deep left field for a solo home run, providing CBA with a 1-0 lead, which would later become the final score.
Despite the loss, Immaculata finishes its season at 22-6, the most wins in the Cust era. It was also the program’s second 20-win season since Cust took over for longtime skipper, and now Athletic Director, Tom Gambino in 2013.
Click below for postgame reaction from Immaculata head coach Kevin Cust with Central Jersey Sports Radio’s Sean Newcomb, presented by Sportsplex at Metuchen: