In one corner: the public school that is making its first appearance ever in the Somerset County Tournament.
In the other: the private school that has been to three straight finals, winning two of them.
Both are among the Top 15 ranked teams in the state, and either would be deserving of the title.
That’s what Saturday will boil down to when second-seed Montgomery battles top-seed and defending champion Rutgers Prep for the 2024 Somerset County Tournament title.
Sure, they’ve faced each other once already, and that game could have gone either way. Montgomery had the early lead and a one-point advantage at the half. But Rutgers Prep came out on top.
Now, we get the rematch.
Central Jersey Sports Radio will have coverage of Saturday’s entire Somerset County Tournament Championship Doubleheader, with Mike Pavlichko and Chris Tsakonas calling all the play-by-play. Coverage starts at approximately 2:40 pm for the boys’ game, with the girls’ final – between three-time defending champ Rutgers Prep and Gill St. Bernard’s – tipping off at 1 pm, pregame at 12:40. Click here to listen.
While the Prep girls now have to deal with an ankle injury to sophomore Ava LaMonica suffered in Thursday’s semifinal win against Franklin – though it’s not a break, she’ll at least be out for the county final Saturday – the Argonaut boys just got back someone they were looking to for senior experience this year in John Kelly. The 6-8 forward gives coach Matt Bloom additional length to work with. He’s slowly been finding his game legs, scoring nine points against Oratory Prep on February 10th, then eight against Pingry in the quarterfinals, and seven points and four boards against Hillsborough in the semis, also going 4-of-4 at the line.
As they did Thursday night against the Raiders – and have all year long – the Argonauts want to get up and down the floor, and often do it with ease. That wasn’t easy from the get-go when the teams first met on January 30th, a 62-48 Rutgers Prep win, though Montgomery led 27-26 at halftime.
Montgomery is also dealing with the injury to Ethan Lin, a talented sophomore guard, but the Cougars have won seven straight overall, six since Lin broke his ankle in two places against Hillsborough February third, ending his season.
And the 1-2 combo of Steve Donahue and Bohdan Bieketov – who only came to the U.S. a few months ago from the Ukraine – has been hard to stop of late. The two combined for 38 points in the semifinals against Watchung Hills, while Bieketov had a double-double with 11 rebounds.
Click below to hear both coaches talk about the semifinal matchup, and scroll down for more info on the game:
MORE ON THE SOMERSET COUNTY TOURNAMENT BOYS’ FINAL:
(1) Rutgers Prep (18-6) vs. (2) Montgomery (21-2)
When: Saturday, 3 pm
Where: Montgomery Township High School
Broadcast Team: Mike Pavlichko and Chris Tsakonas (LISTEN HERE)
COACHES:
Rutgers Prep: Matt Bloom, 7th season (132-39)
Montgomery: Kris Grundy, 19th season (315, 185)
HOW THEY GOT HERE:
Rutgers Prep: The Argonauts beat 8th-seed Pingry, 82-56, in the quarterfinals at home on Wednesday night, getting 24 points from Myles Parker – to lead all scorers – while big Andrew Kretkwoski chipped in 11, and Rocco Loomis added ten. One night later in the semifinals, they topped four-seed Hillsborough, 69-58. Four players made it into double-figures, as Jacob Canton led this time with 22 points, while Parker added 16, Loomis scored 11, and Kretkowski added ten. Like their first meeting this season in Hillsborough back on January 23rd, by a similar margin of ten points, it was tight all the way, with Prep holding just a two point halftime lead against the Raiders two nights ago before finishing the job in the second half.
Montgomery: The Cougars had their hands full with 7th-seed Gill St. Bernard’s, which has struggled to find its footing after an almost complete roster overhaul in the offseason, but has been playing stronger of late, according to Montgomery coach Kris Grundy. But despite a 30-24 halftime deficit, the Cougars rallied to win, 58-51, behind 24 points from Steve Donahue and 11 from Josh Moore. In the semis, on Thursday, Monty beat third-seed Watchung Hills – in a game heard on Central Jersey Sports Radio – 53-40. Bieketov had a 21-point, 11-rebound double-double, while Donahue added 17.
TOP SCORERS:
Rutgers Prep: Jacob Canton (16.2 ppg, 47 treys), Myles Parker (14.8 points, team-best 60 treys), Andrew Kretkowski (10.8 ppg, 17 treys), Rocco Loomis (10.3 ppg, 46 treys)
Montgomery: Steve Donahue (15.7 ppg, team-best 48 treys), Ethan Lin (13.8 ppg, INJURED), Bohdan Bieketov (11.3 ppg, 2 treys)
TOP REBOUNDERS:
Rutgers Prep: Andrew Kretkowski (6), Jacon Canton (5.4), Myles Parker (5)
Montgomery: Bohdan Bieketov (9.4), Steve Donahue (5.6), Jack Fromelt (4.2)
RECENT MEETINGS: Montgomery has lost six in a row against Rutgers Prep dating back to the 2019-20 season. But the year before, they beat the Argonauts twice. In fact, the Cougars are the last Somerset County public school to beat Rutgers Prep in the regular season. Watchung Hills beat the Argonauts in the COVID-shortened 2021 season, but that was in the “top” Blue Pod Semifinals in. The Warriors went on to beat Gill St. Bernard’s for the title.
SCT HISTORY:
Rutgers Prep: Rutgers Prep played in the very first full Somerset County Tournament title game in 1988, losing as the second-seed to top-seed Bridgewater-Raritan West, 94-66. (Before 1988, the SCT was split into two divisions, and there was an A and a B champion.) Overall, they’re 2-5 in the finals, losing their first four attempts at the trophy, in 2011, 2017 and 2018 in addition to the ’88 trip. They won it all in 2020, beating Watchung Hills, but lost in 2022 to Gill St. Bernard’s, before avenging the defeat last year in the county final. This will be Prep’s fourth straight visit to the SCT title game.
Montgomery: Montgomery is making its first appearance in the finals in school history. Of the current Somerset County schools in the GMC, they’re the 11th team to make an appearance in the finals. And that leaves three schools who’ve never made it: Bernards, Manville and Pingry.



