The Cumiskey brothers are both committed to Seton Hall, but forget about sophomore Carter for a moment, because Casey still has some memories to make in this, his senior year.
Casey Cumiskey scattered three runs over 6 1/3 innings of work, gave up five hits and struck out six, in a 5-3 upset win for the 11th-seeded Chargers at 6th-seed Woodbridge in the GMC Tournament’s second round Monday night.
The win puts Spotswood (14-4) in one of the 4 pm quarterfinal games Wednesday afternoon at North Brunswick’s Community Park against 3rd-seed St. Joseph-Metuchen, a 12-2 winner over 19-seed Metuchen Tuesday evening.

Woodbridge (13-5) got a run in the second on a Dean Fiore two-out triple, but Spotswood got it back in the top of the fourth. Carter Cumiskey reached on a single, then Jackson Walsh beat out the throw from the catcher on another bunt to put runners at first and second with nobody out. Chris Bottigilieri laid down a second bunt, and the first baseman Ty Kobylakiewicz charging went for a force at third but threw it away and Casey Cumiskey came home to score. But after another bunt and a fielder’s choice force at third, Woodbridge starter Eddie Nunez got two Ks to get out of the inning.
And Woodbridge went up 2-1 in the bottom of the third when Shawn Kish singled, then Xavier Diaz drove him in with a walk.
In the top of the fifth, Spotswood small ball and a wacky outfield play got them four runs. Ryan Orth led off with a walk, and Breckyn DeAngelis reached on a hard hit ball deep in the hole to shortstop. Casey Cumsikey then knocked in both runs with a two-RBI triple on a fly ball to right field that the right and centerfielders misplayed, thinking it was in the gap. It landed about 30 feet more toward right field.
After a groundout, another bunt by Jackson Walsh was misplayed by the catcher as Cumiskey came charging home to put Spotswood up 4-2. The Chargers loaded the bases and a walk to Shawn Lennan brought in another run to make it 5-2 before Nunez escaped further damage with a strikeout.
The Barrons got a run back in the bottom of the fifth, making it 5-3 on a groundout to short by Drew Lukachyk., but Shawn Kish made the third out on a hard hit ball deep in the hole to short that Orth fielded cleanly, throwing a bullet to first base to end the inning.
After a 1-2-3 sixth for both teams, and nothing across in the seventh, Woodbridge threatened.
Dean Fiore flew out to lead off, then A.J. Bosch walked, and the Cusmiskey had reached his pitch limit. Spotswood coach Glenny Fredricks brought in Jackson Walsh from second to pitch. He walked Tyler Weber to put runners at first and second with one out. Ty Kobylackiewicz hit it to second, and Weber was erased at second, bringing up cleanup hitter Drew Lukachyk.
But on a 1-2 pitch, Walsh threw a high fastball, Lukachyk took a big cut and missed, and Spotswood had its upset.
Click below for postgame reaction presented by Sportsplex at Metuchen:






